Monday, September 10, 2007

Shorshe Dharosh or Okra in Mustard Sauce


Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket


It’s been almost a year and a half that S has started her daycare/pre-school. Considering that we do not speak almost any English at home, it is fun to hear the smattering of English she has picked up primarily through school. She pronounces the words mostly by hearing which she sometimes gets wrong due to the accent. However I have noticed even if she doesn’t know the meaning of certain words, the context in which she uses them is almost always correct though her rendition makes us laugh out loud.(Yes, we are weird parents, we have fun at the expense of a 3 year old)

Yesterday she was painting some flowers in some obscure colors, she always use colors very imaginatively making you think she has never seen a flower in real life. So she paints these flowers and admires her own work of art by saying “Ei phool gulo khub cherryfull lagche na” (“Aren’t these flowers looking cherryfull?”)

In my vain attempt to correct I said that the word is “CHEERFUL” and not “CHERRYFULL”

But then why should a 3 and half year old listen to her poor mother. So as is her nature she insisted “ Na eta Cherryfull lagche“ (No this looks Cherryfull)

So I said but what does it mean?

And she tells me “Cherry jano na Cherry…sei cherry diye full hoye geche” (“You don’t know cherry” she said “it means with lots and lots of cherries it is full”)

Huh….totally stumped…I demanded no further explanation and gave her a “cherryfull” smile.

Today when she drew a Christmas tree with a coconut on top, I just kept mum.





A Mustard Oil Ad from Dhara


Thanks MalluGirl:D

Back to food now. When Ashwini had raised a question “What is the Gold in your Cuisine?” sometime back, I wondered. Yes I wonder a lot, could have been the wonder kid, stuck to being a wonder mom now.

While I was intently wondering, what to choose, a Dhara print Ad flashed through my dull brain. A lady pouring Mustard Oil while smiling at the camera (no mean feat I tell you) and the ad line screaming “Tel noyto, jeno Galano Shona” (It is not Oil, it is molten Gold).

So that is what it is. Mustard. Shorsher tel aka Mustard Oil and shorshe bata the mustard paste is gold of not only Bengali Cuisine but cuisine of many states in the Eastern Region of India. More about Mustard, in MySpice – Mustard.

I made Shorshe Dharosh or Okra in a Mustard sauce today. It is a traditional bengali recipe that my Ma used to follow.The sharp flavor of the mustard paste and the oil creates a heady mix with the Okra. Tastes best with tender baby okra and can be had with Roti or White Rice though I definitely prefer the latter. It can be an everyday dish but is elegant enough to serve when you have guests over. Also ideal for a strict vegetarian menu as it has no onion or garlic. This goes to Sunita's Think Spice Event which features Mustard this month.


Read more...







What You Need

Okra/Bhindi/Dharosh ~ I had 60 baby okras, tender the better. Did not weigh them and so had to count them……what a task !!! The okra needs to be tender, does not taste good with the okras that are aged. Try frozen baby okras if you don't get fresh.

For Mustard paste







Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket


Mustard seeds/Rai/Shorshe ~ 6 tbsp
Poppy Seeds/KhusKhus/Posto ~ 2 tbsp
Green Chillies ~ 3 (When I say Green Chillies, I always mean the Indian Green Chillies which are really hot)
Salt ~ a pinch

Soak the mustard and poppy seeds in water for 15-20 minutes and then grind together all the above with little water. The paste should not be runny so add little water gradually during grinding. It yielded about 7-8 heaped tbsp of paste .

Tips: Grinding the mustard right is important to get a smooth paste which is NOT bitter. Somehow this was never a cause of concern when the Shil-Nora was used in my home in India. Here I have seen some blenders/grinders do a lousy job of grinding.

If you are dry grinding using a coffe grinder, the paste might get a little bitter. In that case mix the powder (done in the coffee grinder) with salt, green chilli and vinegar and let it rest for half an hour.

When wet grinding, often your attempt to make small quantity of paste might fail. Add all the ingreds listed with little water and run the blender for long enough until you get a smooth paste.

There are some good discussions on getting the right mustard paste here


For Tempering

Nigella seeds/Kalonji/Kalo Jeera ~ 1 tsp loosely packed
Green Chillies ~ 5 chillies slit lengthwise

For the gravy/sauce

Mustard Paste ~ 5 heaped tbsp of the prepared paste
Yogurt ~ 2 heaped tsp
Red Chilli Powder ~ I do not use red chilli powder for my mustard based recipes but you can add a little

Oil ~ Mustard Oil is preferred but you can use Canola. I would not suggest Olive Oil for this dish but if you must go ahead.
Salt

How I Did It

To Prep
Prepare the mustard paste as mentioned
Chop the head and tail off all the okra. Wash, pat dry and then chop else they get slimy

To Cook

Heat Oil in a Kadhai/Frying Pan

Temper with Nigella seeds/Kalonji and Green Chilli. When the spices start sputtering add the washed and dried okra

Sauté the okra for 4-5 minutes with a pinch of turmeric. Do not deep fry them, they should be tender and half cooked. You will know because they will glisten and have turned soft by this time.

Mix the mustard paste with yogurt and add the mixture to the okra

Add salt and red chilli powder

Mix well, add a dash of mustard oil and cover and cook. If you do not have mustard oil, add a little of the cooking oil.

In between remove cover, stir and add a little water (about 7-8 tbsp) Stir intermittently till the okra is done. Take care not to mash up the okra. You want them whole so a gentle stir is enough

I make it moist but gravy is almost dry, the result looks as in the pic

Drizzle a little mustard oil on top before serving






Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket






Trivia: Okra originated in Ethiopian Highlands and was introduced to America during the slave trade. The name Okra is West African in origin. Okra is also called "kingumbo" in some Bantu languages and that is the origin of the American "gumbo". Okra arrived in India after the common era as proved from the fact that the ancient Indian languages has no word for okra though now it is known as "Bhindi" in the Indian language, Hindi.

51 comments:

  1. wow mustard sauce very unique goto to try so i can use this with any other vege too right :)! i remembered one of the gojju seeing your mustard sauce.

    kiddo talk in english is very entertaining right my son just joined 1 week for the day care activity , so it is much relaxing and enjoyable too :)
    ReplyDelete
  2. Ooh baby! this one must be really fiery :). Would love to try this. Mustard oil adds a great flavor to food!

    Convey my cherryful smile to lil' S <3
    ReplyDelete
  3. You know I love okras and will definitely try this. I am sure that after eating it I would be very cherryful :)
    ReplyDelete
  4. Cutie pie Little S :) You are like a mind-reader, dear Sandeepa. The other I was searchign for mustard recipes for "Think spice" event. Check this..it is Shorshe Dharos. I will definitely make this for my parents using your recipe and let you know.
    ReplyDelete
  5. you are back!!!! the Dhara ad with bong-punju angle is hilarious!!!haha...i am staying away from mustard-poppy paste till i have either a food processor or a coffee grinder as u told me the last time..i can just not get the seeds to grind in my normal mixer......meanwhile I'll look at other recipes and keep this for future :)

    and the last time i made kolai daal and aaloo posto, we had a very "enlightening" discussion over ghoti and edeshi food...i had no idea about the either of the terms till my husband and later my in laws enlightened moi!!!! :)
    ReplyDelete
  6. now c'mon. post that christmas tree with the coconut!!
    ReplyDelete
  7. sandeepa..the baby talk of kids is soo sweet...
    ReplyDelete
  8. After reading your post I feel very cherryfull :) ! (But reading this with hungry tummy is making me drool ) This is one of my comfort foods with fresh okra. Usually, I add posto with the mustard, and also throw in some potatoes. Never had it with yogurt and kalonji. Will try it soooon.
    ReplyDelete
  9. i am not a fan of okra but this really looks delicious.. lovely pics :)
    ReplyDelete
  10. Sandeepa something new for me. But the okras look yummy. Viji
    ReplyDelete
  11. Here baby and big okra are all mixed up - think I'll ignore your instructions and try it with the big bhindi anyway! The mustard is what will make me cherryful!
    ReplyDelete
  12. :) Thats a cherryfull post Sandeepa...
    Wow, 6 tbsp mustard seeds... :) We make a pachadi with mustard paste, but only about 1/2 tsp mustard seeds are ground, that too we add yogurt to nuetralize the mustard taste! So I'm kinda scared to try this, but if you vouch for it, I have to try it, to at least know what all that mustard tastes like! :)
    ReplyDelete
  13. Hooray, a recipe using mustard paste AND mustard oil (I've got mustard oil which I'd like to try using) - plus okra, which I love. Now I'm definitely cherryful as well :D And as Sra said, I'm gonna have to use regular okra...
    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi,

    You have great blog. Would you mind to have a link exchange with me?

    Please email me if you are interested.

    my email : kamarul[at]hoteltravel[dot]com

    I'd like to exchange your link with our company website.

    Thanks.

    Note: You can delete this comment.
    ReplyDelete
  15. Sandeepa!!I am back and slowly started visiting blogs, missed so many of u'r wonderful recipes!!
    wondering where to start though!!
    ReplyDelete
  16. Hmmm... am getting to taste some bengali food as my neighbour is married to a bong. We had posto and bhajas with khichuri for dinner last night. My contribution was rasam, a raw banana curry and a konkani mixed veg dish.

    My neighbour surprised me with rasam one day... I'll surprise her with this. Seems quite easy :-)

    Thanks :-)
    ReplyDelete
  17. Oh dear, Sandeepa: here, let me translate on behalf on S...she means that the flowers are looking bright and red, just like cherries! "cherryful"may not be in the dictionary right now, but it is a great descriptive word :)
    ReplyDelete
  18. LOL at big S, DD1 was the same did not speak a word of English when she started Pre-K and after a year she started correcting our pronounciation so laugh all you want NOW.

    Oh and the recipe with mustard sauce have to be tried it looks delicious. I have never heard of mustard oil/mustard sauce till my pre-blog days.
    ReplyDelete
  19. Hahaha!! My kids are the opposite! They speak English,understand some Kannada.We teach my son (who is understands lot less Kannada than Trish) Kannada curse words,ask him to repeat and laugh until we get stomach ache.We are not just weird but nasty parents too!:D
    Great entry for mustard,looks and sounds good.Thanks for the recipe girl,made me very cherryful too!:)
    ReplyDelete
  20. ohh!my eyes are watering at the pungency just by reading! the ad still brought a cherry-full smile!cute daughter u have!
    ReplyDelete
  21. I have bhindi in my refrigerator, will try this version soon, love the mustardy look bhindis are carrying..If I am not wrong u said it goes well with rice, right!
    ReplyDelete
  22. Sandeepa.....the recipe is new and refreshing to look :-)
    Will try it out for sure....
    ReplyDelete
  23. thanks for dropping by at our blog.

    "cherryfull" is more apt for flower than "cheerful". "cherryfull" = bright and full like a lot of cherries.

    my nephew who's about seven now calls a children park - "the jungle gym". so you know where this leads :).

    reg the coconut on top of a christmas tree - its called artistic license. :)
    ReplyDelete
  24. hey, this sounds so good, want to try this soon :)
    ReplyDelete
  25. very authentic looking recipe. will the mustard give a bitter taste? looks yum!
    ReplyDelete
  26. ROFL :))) Hilarious is not the words...cherryfull and and X'mas tree with cocounut on top did crack me....I am stil giggling thinking of it :)))

    Well, one doubt, can I freeze this mustard paste for future use? and if yes, how long I can freeze it?
    ReplyDelete
  27. Little S antics always bring Cherryful smiles... tomar machha besara baniyechilam... darun!!! now it's darosh's turn :)
    ReplyDelete
  28. oooooh!!! okra is my FAV!!!!! This looks fiery!!! And different!!! Thanx...
    A big cherryfull smile to u and S!!!
    ReplyDelete
  29. Sandeepa, that's one cherryful post indeed....the okra looks great...I make it too, but without the yogurt. Hey, btw, wasn't this supposed to be send over to me :D
    ReplyDelete
  30. This is quite a unique recipe....never heard of mustard sauce before....little S's baby talk was so cute and endearing:)
    ReplyDelete
  31. Roopa
    I am not sure about other veggies. We do it with some specific veggies only. But if you try let me know

    Musical
    The mustard oil that i get here does not have that much pungency, pretty mild I would say. Not really very fiery

    Cynthia
    Try with tender okras alone

    Pragyan
    Checked the site. But mustard paste is not bitter if grinded right, isn't it ?

    Moi
    Yes the grinder plays A VERY IMPORTANT role in getting the right paste. I have spent years with getting aslightly bitter mustard paste which I had to rectify with vinegar & what not. Shall update post with grinding tips

    "Ghoti" & "bangal" food is a topic of many foodie addas :) My in-lwas are coming this week and they are "bangal" so maybe you will see more bangal food if I get time to blog

    Bee
    Does it help that the tree had two sticks potruding from beneath which were apparently legs of the tree !!! Sigh....

    Rajitha
    No longer baby talk, it is pretty adult talk but more opinionated :)

    Mystic
    Even I added poppy seeds to the mustard and the yogurt is not the norm always.

    Nags
    You don't love Bhindi !!!! How can you ?

    Viji
    Thanks :)
    ReplyDelete
  32. Sra

    What I meant is get the tender ones, you know the ones that snap easily

    Sig

    Use only 5 tbsp of the paste. There were a lot of okras you see. If you have less reduce the amount of paste.
    Say with 30 okras try with 2-3 tbsp of paste

    Shammi

    Regular okra is fine, only they should be tender you don't want the tough one here

    Padmaja

    Welcome back

    Ragga

    How did you like posto ? was it aloo-posto or posto bora ? You must have had a nice mix, sounds interesting with your rasam and her khicdi. BTW I make sambhar at home pretty often and love Rasam :)

    Nupur

    Ha ha....good explanation...life with Dale has taught you a lot

    Indo
    As I had said in DMC to enforce the Bengali we do not let her speak English at home and so she says whatever she has picked up at school But I know the days are not far. She anyway tends to correct me in almost all other aspects of life :) as she is BIG now

    Asha

    You are bad !!! I can imagine T roaming around your Coorgi home uttering such stuff :)

    Mallugirl

    Hey come on not that pungent, really

    Padma

    For me everything goes with Rice :D
    ReplyDelete
  33. Sirisha

    Thanks:)

    Lakshmi

    Good explanation:)

    Richa

    I was thinking of you when I made this. Remmeber you had said if there is a veggie with mustard dish ?

    Sharmi

    Grinding the mustard right is really important. If you have a good mixie, grind the mustard seeds with salt, green chillies & poppy seeds. Dry grinding at times makes it bitter

    Shn

    :) yeah imagine that

    I usually store it for a week. Do not use mustard paste that often though.

    Mandira

    Machcha Besara tastes great with salmon too

    Manasi

    Not really that fiery by my standards :)

    Sunita
    It was for you. Did I forget to mention, will update soon

    Priyanka
    Thanks
    ReplyDelete
  34. shilpa(Aayisrecipes)Sep 11, 2007 11:38 AM
    Hahahaha..your kid is so smart :).

    Mustard sauce with bhindi? thats a very unique dish. Until I started reading your blog, I didn't know mustard paste was used so abundantly in Bong cooking.
    ReplyDelete
  35. I guess every cuisine has lots of similarities, We make lots of mustard base dishes (curries n stews). Never had okra in mustard sauce, instead of green chillies we use red. I will try ur version next time.

    Even my son is doing this kind of funny stuff.:) Its always "CHERRYFUL" to watch them:)
    ReplyDelete
  36. Sandeepa, I love sorshe hdarosh, somehow mine doesn't come out as good as my moms! I'll try your version sometiem soon. Thanks for the tip about soaking in vinegar if using a coffee grinder. I have started to use it instead of my blender which takes ages and I need to gring a LOT of sorshe at a time. I had been told to dry grind along with salt, but it hasn't helped much. Thanks again for the tip!

    "Cherryful", has me giggling, she is so so right when you think about it!
    ReplyDelete
  37. Sandeepa. I believe this is a very nice way of cooking okra! I love it!
    ReplyDelete
  38. Hi Sandeepa, Good catch. I don't know why they say it has a bitter taste..as you said, if grinded right, it does not..and thanks to you, I am now a major mustard based curry fan :) Soon my blog is going to be "Copy of bongcookbook.com" :) :) :) Btw, we do share a lot about Bangalore :)
    ReplyDelete
  39. Hi Sandeepa -- few things here! First, just love the story of the darling girl with her cherryful coloring, and the coconut on the Christmas tree -- too sweet! :)

    Also even though I don't speak the language, those actors in the commercial transcend language barriers before the subtitles come up -- I enjoyed that too :)

    Lastly, thank you for the great tips for mustard paste. I have had the problem of bitter mustard and right away see the first thing I should have done was soak the seeds. Now, I only have about half-dozen more okras left here on my plants, but your photo looks so good I will have to try nonetheless. Thanks for the great post :)
    ReplyDelete
  40. loved reading the cherryful story of cute little S.
    Okra in mustard sauce is new to me .. I do not add mustard in my food except for tadkas..
    ReplyDelete
  41. Hi, Good to see you back.

    Please give little S a big hug. And please don't laugh at her. the innovative colours and use of words, show individuality and emotional independence.

    About the mustard oil ad bit.... 'Tel to noy jeno golano shona'was for Arati Mustard Oil, famous copy most probably written by Kamalika Bhattacharyya (a former Bengali news reader in DD.

    Shorshe dhnerosh.... good reminder. Will try this weekend. Have fun.
    ReplyDelete
  42. Haven't heard of this,Sandeepa..but I would love to taste this combo of Okras bathed in mustard and other spices!!:)
    ReplyDelete
  43. Strangely, I have never tasted this dish. Anything with mustard, I love, so I expect to rectify that pretty quickly. :-)
    ReplyDelete
  44. This post has made me very cherryfull :D Lil S is so cute! By popular demand you have to post the picture of the xmas tree with the coconut! I narrate lil S's annecdotes to my hubby and we have a hearty laugh over it!

    I have to show the dhara ad to my co-sister, she's a bong married to a panju. Come to think of it, I'm craving to have some bengali food!
    ReplyDelete
  45. You know Sandeepa, I dont like prashant at all, ppl are rigging for him from Nepal 24X7, I feel so bad for good singers like Emon, Chang. I cried when they were eliminated.... But u know what? the naked truth is Prashant gonna win this II3, he never came in Danger zone at all....well lots of II talk

    Now coming to the sambhar recipe, this udipi one is different than other bcoz it has only urad dal in the paste while in others u will find all the dals n lil rice too.

    Enjoy this has been the longest comment!
    ReplyDelete
  46. Hey Sandeepa... I hate Prashant too just as you do and Hope that Amit wins the Indian Idol 3 title. ( I saw ur comment on Padma's blog..:D ).

    For me mustard has a very strong taste which supresses the light Okra taste.. dont you think so?.. will have to try it to decide myself..:D.. thanks for sharing the recipe dear..
    ReplyDelete
  47. Your three year old is super cute. O thomakey English shikiye debe dekho!! You know, I missed my mom so much when reading this. She made shoreshey bata for a prawn curry and I have dared to bother because of the fuss. Wouldn't it be simpler to mix some poppy seed paste with wholegrain mustard? She doesn't think it would work!!
    ReplyDelete
  48. Absolutely one of my favourite dishes . I add a little raw mustard oil just before taking it off the stove -gives just the right touch of pungency . Oh lil S is absolutely a shona - cherryful indeed ! Very lyrically descriptive !!
    ReplyDelete
  49. Can i do the paste without khus khus? I have all of the other ingredients with me
    ReplyDelete
  50. Anon

    Go ahead skip khus khus :)
    ReplyDelete
  51. hello!
    you can try out potoler dorma with chingri stuffings! Tastes great!

    Sujoy
    ReplyDelete

Thanks for your Comments. I hope you will be nice and not Spam.